letter to the editor from Richard Corbett MEP

13 January 2008

Sunday Telegraph

Dear Editor,

Christopher Booker's article (6 January) supporting those MEPs who attempted to shout down the Portuguese Prime Minister at a ceremony in the European Parliament is ill informed.

Moderate visual "demonstrations", like wearing T-shirts with slogans or waving a small banner, are tolerated in the European Parliament, unlike in most national parliaments. What is forbidden is attempting to disrupt proceedings or shouting down a speaker.

Such behaviour, although rare in the European Parliament, is not actually "unprecedented" - but when it happens the TV cameras remain trained on the speaker - just as is the rule in the House of Commons. To describe this as "censorship" is preposterous - on the contrary, to
have switched the cameras to the demonstrators would have been giving in to an attempt by a small hooligan element to censure the speakers.

Yours,

Richard Corbett

Labour MEP for Yorkshire & Humber
Blenheim Terrace, Leeds